<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="static/style.xsl"?><OAI-PMH xmlns="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/ http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/OAI-PMH.xsd"><responseDate>2026-11-22T21:10:27Z</responseDate><request verb="GetRecord" identifier="oai:vdu.lt:20.500.12259/119992" metadataPrefix="oai_dc">https://portalcris.vdu.lt/server/oai/request</request><GetRecord><record><header><identifier>oai:vdu.lt:20.500.12259/119992</identifier><datestamp>2025-07-12T07:09:39Z</datestamp><setSpec>com_20.500.12259_33778</setSpec><setSpec>com_20.500.12259_36909</setSpec><setSpec>col_20.500.12259_112372</setSpec></header><metadata><oai_dc:dc xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:doc="http://www.lyncode.com/xoai" xmlns:oai_dc="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/ http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc.xsd">
   <dc:title>Ar asmeninių ūkių suteikimas piliečiams kaimo vietovėje užkerta kelią pretendentams atkurti nuosavybės teises į žemę natūra?</dc:title>
   <dc:title>Does the fact of the distribution of the land as personal farming land to villagers takes away the right of pretenders to restitute private property rights to the same piece of the land?</dc:title>
   <dc:creator>Sulikienė, Kristina</dc:creator>
   <dc:contributor>Meškys, Linas</dc:contributor>
   <dc:subject>nuosavybės teisių atkūrimas į žemę</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>asmeninių ūkių žemėnaudos</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>socialinis teisingumas</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>teisėti lūkesčiai</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>restitution of the land property</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>personal farming</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>social justice</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>just expectations</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>Magistro darbas / Master Thesis (ETD_MGR)</dc:subject>
   <dc:subject>Teisė / Law (S001)</dc:subject>
   <dc:description>Magistriniame tyrimo darbe analizuojamos žemės nuosavybės Lietuvoje istorinės ir teisinės prielaidos bei iš to išplaukiantis nuosavybės teisių atkūrimo procesas, kurio didžiausias kliuvinys savininkams, siekusiems atkurti nuosavybės teises į žemę natūra pasirodė esąs asmeninių ūkių šioje žemėje skyrimas. Darbe išanalizuotos problemos, su kuriomis praktiškai susiduria asmenys, siekiantys įgyvendinti savo subjektinę ir Konstitucijos ginamą teisę į nuosavybę. Atkreipiamas dėmesys, jog Lietuvos teisės mokslo autoriai beveik neanalizuoja Žemės reformos istorinių ir teisinių pagrindų, o apsiriboja vien tik teoretiniais svarstymais apie restitucijos idėjos tobulumą, neanalizuodami nuosavybės teisių atkūrimo tam tikrų įstatymų ir poįstatyminių aktų taikymo problemų vykdomosios valdžios institucijose kaip mirusios teisės normos apraiškos fenomeno. Darbe siekiama pažvelgti giliai ir išsamiai į Lietuvos teismų darbą, kuris buvo atliktas nagrinėjant žemės teisės bylas, kuriose susikirto asmeninių ūkių įgijėjų bei žemės savininkų, siekusių susigrąžinti žemę natūra, interesai, analizuojamos teisės taikymo ir aiškinimo taisyklės bei prieinama išvados, jog netgi konkrečią teisės taikymo ir aiškinimo taisyklę sukūrę ir įgyvendinę teisėjai kartais jos iš viso netaiko. Todėl darbe prieinama išvados, jog būtina užtikrinti teisėjų darbo kokybę, kontrolę bei etiką, nes netinkamai nagrinėjant bylas, susijusias su pamatine demokratine vertybe – teise į nuosavybę, yra pakertamas konstitucinis valstybės pamatas. Darbe yra apibendrinamos Lietuvos Teismų praktikos bylos ir nustatoma, jog yra 4 taisyklės, reglamentuojančios teisės taikymą ir aiškinimą žemės nuosavybės teisių atkūrimo bylose. Darbe iškeliamos 2 hipotezės, pirmoji - jog žemės nuosavybės atkūrimo įstatymo tam tikri straipsniai tebuvo mirusi teisės norma, praktikoje beveik neįgyvendinama, jeigu vykdomosios valdžios pareigūnai atsisakydavo ją vykdyti. Antroji hipotezė - nuosavybės teisių atkūrimo procesui nebuvo pasirengta tinkamai, nes šį procesą apsunkino tai, jog nebuvo panaikintas Lietuvos Aukščiausiosios Tarybos nutarimas „Dėl sodybinių sklypų išplėtimo“ . Asmeninių ūkių įgijėjų ir žemės savininkų priešprieša taip pat paaiškintina ideologiniu nesuderinamumu tarp komunistinių ir liberaliųjų idėjų. Žemės savininko ir vykdomosios valdžios atstovo priešprieša paaiškinama išankstiniu konfliktu, užprogramuotu privačios ir viešosios teisės susidūrime. Kokybinio tyrimo duomenų analizė atskleidžia, jog iš esmės asmeninių ūkių suteikimo faktas žemėje, kurią siekia atkurti savininkai, neužkerta kelio nuosavybės teisių atkūrimui į tokią žemę.</dc:description>
   <dc:description>In this resarch the problems of the 1991 Lithuanian Land Reform are being analyzed. The main problem is that starting the Reform mentioned Lithuania‘s legislature didn‘t postpone the desicion of the Parliament, 26th of July, 1990, regarding establishement of the personal farming of villagers. According to the idea of the restitution, based in Lithuania‘s legal constitutional tradition and based on the just expectations, Land Reform should have been great democratical project, partly restoring previous civil order, which was destroyed by the Soviet occupation by nacionalizing all immovable property. In this paper having analysed Lithuania‘s scientific papers regarding Land Reform issues author didn‘t choose solely thoeretical analysis as Lithuanian scientist didn‘t analyse this problem of two social groups interests claiming the right to the same piece of land. That is why author used broad range of the social science methodology, interviewed plaintiffs and land owners, analyzed Lithuanian Supreme Court‘s practice regarding cases between personal farm owner and the real owner of the same land according to the restitution idea. It is concluded that Lithuanian Land Reform partly collapsed because the law of the restitution didn‘t come into practice what means that law remained unimplemented. The results of the research suggest that not only legislature didn‘t guarantee the due process of law during the Land Reform, but also judges and the attorneys where not ready for such kind of cases and most of the time such cases where decided wrongly - not following legal practice rules which where adopted by Lithuanian Supreme Court already long time ago. The biggest Lithuania‘s problem is that there is no mechanism of controlling judges, the rules regarding control of judges as it is shown in the case study example doesn‘t work in practice in Lithuania. Author states that on of the biggest problems in the process of the restitution of the land property was the fact that officials of the legislature didn‘t implement valid Land laws, but all the work of interpreting law have left to judges. As until now there is no adequate control of judges in Lithuania, and only since 2009 there is practice of the concuring oppinion in Lithuania‘s courts, restitution of the land property of such land, which is ruled by the third parties – so called personal farming land owners – becomes very complicated and hardly it is succesfull to achieve restitution of the land property, when legislature, state‘s officials and even courts many times refuse to use valid Land laws in legal practice. In this research author derives 4 existing rules of the legal practice regarding cases where restitution problems are being solved. Regarding those rules author analyses court cases and investigates, whether judges have followed those specific rules. In this work author points at the problems of the legal science in Lithuania, when during two decades of independence no scientific research regarding chosen problem has been done. Legal scientists most often make no practical research, but mostly rewrite the norms and laws, claiming, that the idea of the restitution of the land property was constitutional and democratical approach of the state. No practical difficulties trying to protect the rights promised in the Constitution are being analyzed. That comes from the Soviet times when the science and the courts were strongly controlled by the Comunist party. But nowadays in the author‘s oppinion there is nothing to fear and land reform‘s problems must be analyzed trying to find out the main reasons that caused difficulties of the restitution of the property in Lithuania in those areas where big groups of people received personal farming land ownership. In this research author makes case analysis analyzing cases of the Supreme Court of Lithuania, also one case which is pending at the moment in Kaunas district court and concludes that during land reform big mechanism of controlling and terorizing land owners has been created, and this mechanism can cause situations that land owner would give up because of the activities of judges, procecutors, states lawyers and the lawyers of the defendants. Respondent analysis shows that many times lawyers has worked not for the interests of the clients in such kind of cases. Courts made desicions following emotions, corruption and other factors, incompatible with the valid law regarding Land Resform and the Civil Process Law. The analysis of the Supreme Court Cases show that in some cases courts didn‘t follow their own practice and legal rules, broke the law and Government‘s desicions concerning personal farming land‘s legal regulation. In this research 2 hypothesis are being raised. The first hypothesis suggests that some parts of the law concerning restitution of property in Lithuania have left as dead norms of the law, because were never implemented and used in real legal practice, if officials refused to follow those norms. The second hypothesis states, that the process was initially made controversial because of the valid law concerning fullfilling needs of the villagers distributing pieces of land of 2 hectares in the villages. It is also concluded, that according to political philosophy, such project had to collapse, as marxism is incompatible with liberalism, as well as public law gets into conflict with the private law. The results of the research suggest that even though the land was given to the third parties as the personal farming land, it is not a factor that can ban real land owner from the implementing his right of the restitution to such land property.</dc:description>
   <dc:date>2020-12-22T20:21:19Z</dc:date>
   <dc:date>2020-12-22T20:21:19Z</dc:date>
   <dc:date>2010-06-10</dc:date>
   <dc:type>type::text::thesis::master thesis</dc:type>
   <dc:identifier>https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12259/119992</dc:identifier>
   <dc:language>lt</dc:language>
   <dc:rights>open access</dc:rights>
   <dc:format>97 p.</dc:format>
   <dc:format>application/pdf</dc:format>
   <dc:format>application/pdf</dc:format>
</oai_dc:dc>
</metadata></record></GetRecord></OAI-PMH>